How to Reheat Fish Sticks in an Air Fryer | Crispy, Fast, Beginner‑Safe

Every product is independently reviewed and selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Reheating fish sticks sounds simple, until you end up with soggy breading, dried-out fish, or that unmistakable “leftover freezer” smell. I’ve reheated fish sticks in just about every way over the years (oven, microwave, skillet, toaster oven), and the air fryer is hands-down the most reliable method for getting them hot, crisp, and actually enjoyable again.

This guide walks you through exactly how to reheat fish sticks in an air fryer, with clear temperatures, timing, visual cues, and common mistakes I see in real home kitchens. If you follow this method, you’ll get crisp outsides, moist fish inside, and safe results, on the first try.

Why Reheating Fish Sticks Is Tricky

Fish sticks are a combination food:

• Lean fish that dries out quickly
• Breaded coating that absorbs moisture as it cools

What most beginners don’t realize is that once fish sticks cool, steam gets trapped inside the breading, softening it. Reheating the wrong way (especially in the microwave) adds more moisture and finishes the job, leaving you with limp, rubbery sticks.

In real kitchens, the problem isn’t underheating, it’s reheating too gently or with trapped moisture.

That’s why the air fryer works so well.

Why This Method Works

The air fryer reheats fish sticks using circulating dry heat, which does three important things:

• Evaporates surface moisture This re-crisps the breading instead of steaming it.
• Reheats quickly and evenly Short cook time prevents the fish inside from drying out.
• Restores texture, not just temperature You get crunch you can hear when you bite, not just warm food.

In repeated testing at home, temperatures between 350–375°F consistently gave the best balance of:

• Crisp exterior
• Moist interior
• No burnt breading

Higher heat browns too fast. Lower heat dries the fish before the coating crisps.

Ingredients & Tools You’ll Need

Ingredients

• Leftover cooked fish sticks (homemade or frozen brand, already cooked)

Optional (Only If Needed)

• Neutral oil spray (avocado or canola) Use sparingly—only if breading looks very dry

Tools

• Air fryer (basket or tray-style both work)
• Tongs (for safe flipping)
• Instant-read thermometer (recommended for food safety)

Budget & Substitution Notes

• No need for foil or parchment, these block airflow.
• If you don’t have an oil spray, brushing lightly with oil works, but avoid drenching.

How to Reheat Fish Sticks in an Air Fryer

Step 1: Preheat the Air Fryer

• Temperature: 350°F (177°C)
• Time: 3–5 minutes

Why this matters: Starting with a hot air fryer helps the breading crisp immediately instead of slowly absorbing heat and turning chewy.

Step 2: Arrange Fish Sticks in a Single Layer

• Place fish sticks flat and spaced apart
• Do not stack or overlap

Real kitchen observation: Overcrowding traps steam. Even one overlapping stick can turn the rest soggy.

Step 3: Lightly Oil (Only If Needed)

• If breading looks dry or patchy, mist lightly with oil
• Skip this step if they already look evenly coated

Common mistake: Too much oil makes the breading greasy and soft—not crisp.

Step 4: Reheat

• Temperature: 350°F
• Time: 3–4 minutes, then flip
• Continue cooking: 2–4 more minutes

Total time: 5–8 minutes, depending on thickness

What to Look For

• Breading turns golden and crisp
• You should hear a faint sizzle in the last minute
• Fish sticks feel firm, not spongy, when pressed with tongs

Step 5: Check Doneness & Safety

• Internal temperature should reach 165°F (74°C)
• If not hot enough, cook in 1-minute bursts

Food safety note: Fish should be reheated only once. If it’s been reheated before, it’s safer to discard.

Step 6: Rest Briefly, Then Serve

• Let rest 1 minute before eating
• This allows steam to escape without softening the crust

Pro Tips & Best Practices (From Real Kitchens)

• Don’t use the microwave first. Once breading is steamed, the air fryer can’t fully fix it.
• Thicker fish sticks need lower heat, longer time. Thin sticks reheat faster but burn easier.
• Flip gently. Aggressive flipping knocks off breading.
• Serve immediately. Fish sticks lose crispness fast once reheated.
• Clean the basket afterward. Fish oils linger and affect the next batch of food.

Common Beginner Mistakes to Avoid

• Reheating at 400°F “to save time” → burnt coating, dry fish
• Overcrowding the basket → soggy breading
• Adding water or covering → steaming, not crisping
• Reheating more than once → texture and safety issues

FAQ: Reheating Fish Sticks in an Air Fryer

Why did my fish sticks turn out dry?

Usually from too high heat or too long cooking time. Stick to 350°F and check early.

Can I reheat frozen fish sticks in the air fryer?

Yes, but this guide is for already cooked leftovers. Frozen fish sticks usually need 390–400°F for 10–12 minutes, depending on brand.

Do I need to thaw fish sticks before reheating?

No. Leftover cooked fish sticks should be reheated straight from the fridge, not frozen.

Can I reheat battered fish sticks the same way?

Mostly yes, but battered coatings brown faster. Start checking at 4–5 minutes total.

Is it safe to reheat fish sticks?

Yes, as long as they:

• Were stored properly (≤40°F)
• Are reheated to 165°F
• Are reheated only once

Can I reheat fish sticks with fries at the same time?

You can, but fries usually need higher heat. Expect slightly less crisp fish unless you cook separately.

When NOT to Use This Method

Avoid reheating fish sticks in an air fryer if:

• The fish is already overcooked or dried out
• The breading is falling off completely
• The fish has been left out at room temperature too long

In those cases, the air fryer won’t fix quality or safety issues.

Alternative Reheating Methods (Quick Comparison)

Oven

Pros: Good for large batches Cons: Slower, less crisp unless very hot When to use: Feeding a crowd

Skillet

Pros: Very crisp Cons: More oil, uneven heating When to use: Small portions, careful attention

Microwave

Pros: Fast Cons: Soggy, rubbery texture When to use: Only if texture doesn’t matter

Conclusion: Reliable, Crispy Results Every Time

If you want fish sticks that actually taste good the second time around, reheating fish sticks in an air fryer is the most dependable method. With moderate heat, proper spacing, and short cook times, you can bring back crisp breading without drying out the fish inside.

In everyday home kitchens, this method works because it respects what fish needs: gentle reheating, dry heat, and good airflow. Follow these steps, trust the visual cues, and you’ll get confident, safe, and satisfying results, no guesswork required.

If you reheat fish sticks often, this is one technique worth memorizing.