Is It Better to Reheat Steak in an Air Fryer or Microwave | Juicy, Safe, and Beginner‑Friendly Guide

Every product is independently reviewed and selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Reheating steak sounds simple, until you end up with rubbery, gray meat that barely resembles the delicious steak you cooked the night before. If you’re standing in your kitchen wondering “is it better to reheat steak in an air fryer or microwave?”, you’re not alone.

This guide breaks it all down in clear, practical terms, no chef jargon, no guesswork. We’ll compare both methods, explain why one works better, and show you exactly how to reheat steak without drying it out.

Whether you’re short on time or want restaurant‑quality leftovers, this article will help you choose the best method for your situation.

Is it Better to Reheat Steak in an Air Fryer or Microwave (The Real Problem With Reheating Steak)

Steak is expensive, and wasting it hurts, especially when reheating turns a juicy ribeye into something tough and lifeless.

The challenge? Steak is already cooked. Reheating it means adding heat without overcooking, which is tricky because:

• Steak has low moisture compared to foods like pasta or soup
• High heat tightens muscle fibers, making meat chewy
• Microwaves and air fryers heat food in very different ways

So, is it better to reheat steak in an air fryer or microwave?

Short answer: Air fryer = better texture and flavor and Microwave = faster but higher risk of rubbery steak

Let’s dig into why.

Why This Method Matters: The Science of Reheating Steak

To understand which method is better, it helps to know what happens to steak when it’s reheated.

What Heat Does to Steak

Steak is made up of:

• Muscle fibers
• Fat
• Water (moisture)

When reheated:

• Too much heat = moisture loss
• Fast, uneven heating = tough texture
• Dry environment = leathery steak

The goal is to:

• Warm the steak gently
• Keep moisture inside
• Avoid pushing it past its original doneness

This is where the air fryer and microwave behave very differently.

Air Fryer vs Microwave: At-a-Glance Comparison

Feature	Air Fryer	Microwave
Texture	Firm outside, juicy inside	Often rubbery
Flavor	Maintains steak flavor	Can taste “flat”
Speed	4–8 minutes	1–3 minutes
Moisture retention	Good (with prep)	Poor
Best for	Thick cuts, quality steak	Thin slices, emergencies
Beginner-friendly	Yes	Yes (with care)

Reheating Steak in an Air Fryer (Best Overall Method)

Why Reheating Steak in an Air Fryer Works

An air fryer reheats steak using circulating hot air, which:

• Heats more evenly than a microwave
• Helps re-crisp the outside
• Keeps the inside warm without overcooking (when done correctly)

This method is especially good for:

• Ribeye
• New York strip
• Sirloin
• Filet mignon

What You’ll Need (Air Fryer Method)

• Cooked steak (room temperature if possible)
• Air fryer
• Aluminum foil (optional)
• Cooking spray or a few drops of oil
• Meat thermometer (recommended, not required)

Optional Add-Ons

• Butter or garlic butter
• Beef broth (1–2 teaspoons)
• Fresh herbs (thyme, rosemary)

How to Reheat Steak in an Air Fryer

Step 1: Let the Steak Rest

Take the steak out of the fridge 15–20 minutes before reheating.

This helps it heat evenly and prevents a cold center.

Step 2: Preheat the Air Fryer

Set your air fryer to 250–275°F (120–135°C).

Low heat is key. High heat will overcook the steak fast.

Step 3: Prepare the Steak

• Lightly brush or spray with oil
• Optional: wrap loosely in foil to retain moisture

Step 4: Reheat Gently

• Place steak in the basket
• Heat for 3–5 minutes
• Flip halfway through

For thicker steaks (over 1 inch), you may need 6–8 minutes total.

Step 5: Check Temperature

Aim for:

• Medium-rare: ~120–125°F
• Medium: ~130–135°F

Remove immediately once warmed.

Step 6: Rest and Serve

Let the steak rest for 2 minutes, then serve.

Result: Warm, juicy steak with good texture.

Pro Tips for Air Fryer Steak Reheating

• Low and slow wins – never rush with high heat
• Add a teaspoon of broth or butter before reheating
• Avoid stacking steaks
• Use foil for lean cuts (like filet)

Common Air Fryer Mistakes

• Reheating at 400°F
• Skipping the flip
• Overcooking “just to be safe”

Reheating Steak in the Microwave (Fast but Risky)

Why the Microwave Is Tricky for Steak

Microwaves heat food by exciting water molecules. Since steak has uneven moisture, this causes:

• Hot spots
• Overcooked edges
• Tough, rubbery texture

That said, it can work in a pinch.

What You’ll Need (Microwave Method)

• Cooked steak
• Microwave-safe plate
• Microwave-safe lid or damp paper towel
• Butter or broth (optional)

How to Reheat Steak in the Microwave (Safely)

Step 1: Slice the Steak

Cut into ½-inch slices for more even heating.

Step 2: Add Moisture

• Place steak on plate
• Add 1–2 teaspoons broth or butter

Step 3: Cover Loosely

Use a microwave lid or damp paper towel.

Step 4: Heat in Short Bursts

• Microwave at 50% power
• Heat for 30 seconds at a time
• Flip or stir between bursts

Step 5: Stop Early

Remove when just warm—not hot.

Result: Acceptable steak when time is limited.

Pro Tips for Microwave Reheating

• Never microwave steak whole
• Always use lower power
• Stop heating before it seems ready

Common Microwave Mistakes

• Full power heating
• Overheating “just one more minute”
• Skipping moisture

FAQ: Common Questions About Reheating Steak

1. Is it better to reheat steak in an air fryer or microwave?

Air fryer is better for flavor, texture, and moisture. Microwave is faster but riskier.

2. Can you reheat steak without drying it out?

Yes, use low heat, add moisture, and avoid overcooking.

3. What temperature should reheated steak reach?

About 120–135°F, depending on doneness.

4. Is it safe to reheat steak more than once?

Food safety guidelines recommend reheating only once.

5. Can you reheat steak straight from the fridge?

Yes, but letting it sit at room temperature improves results.

6. Does steak taste the same after reheating?

It won’t be identical, but air fryer reheating comes very close.

Alternative Methods for Reheating Steak

Skillet (Very Good Option)

• Low heat
• Add butter
• Flip frequently

Oven (Good for Large Portions)

• 250°F
• Covered with foil
• Slower but reliable

Sous Vide (Best, but Advanced)

• Requires equipment
• Excellent results

Final Verdict: Air Fryer or Microwave

So, is it better to reheat steak in an air fryer or microwave?

Air fryer if you care about:

• Juiciness
• Texture
• Flavor

Microwave if you:

• Need speed
• Use proper technique
• Accept minor texture loss

Quick Recap

• Air fryer = best overall
• Microwave = fastest, least forgiving
• Low heat + moisture = success

Reheating steak doesn’t have to be disappointing. With the right method, you can enjoy leftovers that still feel like a treat, not a compromise.

If you want safe, cost-effective, and delicious results, the air fryer is your best friend.